NYSTC Equity Challenge-Week 5

Reflect

Only editable by group admins

  • Last updated March 31, 2022 at 3:41 AM
  • Evidence visible to public
Reflect on and answer the following questions: How do you experience privilege and marginalization? Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials? How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?

All posted evidence

Reflect

How do you experience privilege and marginalization?

I experience privilege in my perceived whiteness, economic status, ableism, and sexual orientation. I am sometimes marginalized for my female identity. Overall my privileges outweigh my marginalization. The Buzzfeed quiz from "Stretching Our Thinking" helped to identify these areas.

Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials?

As a woman scientist, I think that my young female students see me reflected in my class. Within my curriculum I try to incorporate all colors and genders. For example I have posters in my room that represent a diverse group of scientists in my room. I intentionally use practice problems with an array of names in the questions. I lean on Khan Academy for notes that include diverse authors. Within short videos of content/scientist references, I intentionally use mirrors. For example I have a video with Niel deGrasse Tyson in which he is having a conversation about tides with a black colleague. I use a Stephen Hawking video is space and show students that Stephen was in a wheelchair and has accomplished so much. I recently did a dive into Suni and Butch's return back to Earth from the ISS. I include gender neutral phrasings by calling my students "scientists".

How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?

I think I could improve my digital Google Classroom with a section of resources to dive deeper into scientific discoveries, culture, and current research. Having these materials posted digitally will allow all students to have access within school hours. 
jennifernd74y 9 months ago

Reflection

How do you experience privilege and marginalization?
As a white female, I am aware that I benefit from certain privileges that many others do not experience. Being white, I have not been subject to racial prejudice or systemic discrimination. While being female has presented its challenges at times, I still have access to opportunities and resources that are often less available to women of color. 

Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials?
I try to make sure each of my students feels valued and represented in my classroom.  Having a smaller class size makes it easier for me to tailor lessons to ensure each student can see themselves reflected in the curriculum as well as see what others who are marginalized might be experiencing.  

How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?
To make my classroom and school more equitable, I will continue to ensure that my classroom reflects diversity in both materials and discussions, offering representation for all backgrounds and abilities. Additionally, I will strive to create an open, supportive space where all students feel safe to share their perspectives. 
katie-jadhon 10 months ago

Reflection Questions

How do you experience privilege and marginalization?


As a white, middle-class, female, I don't think I have experienced marginalization due to my religion or race, but I feel like in the past, I have experienced some gender discrimination. This was more when I was a teenager working in a male-owned business. I used to work in an orchard that had been family-owned for many, many years, and the two male owners used to tell us what jobs we could and could not do. It was very obvious that the girls worked in the bakery section or at the register.


Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials?


As a science teacher, our curriculum and materials reflect people in general. We don't work out of a textbook and we teach our students to observe and experiment. The students are taught to think critically, communicate, and solve problems. I tell my students that any of them can go into the science field and even if they don't, science affects their everyday lives.


How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?


I make my classroom and school more equitable by teaching my students the science skills in the above prompt, but also by featuring many types of scientists from diverse backgrounds in my classroom with Scientist of the Month. I post a large picture of the person and a write-up of their accomplishments. I also teach my students classroom principles that lean heavily on respect. We discuss that respect is not an option, but a non-negotiable. I encourage my students to bring this mindset into the rest of the day after they leave our classroom.

jsherman 10 months ago

Reflect

I am very fortunate. As a middle-class white male, I have never felt marginalized or discriminated against. I strive to ensure students see themselves reflected by the environment set in our classroom. Physical education and athletics can promote diversity, as a melting pot for all students of different backgrounds. I can make my classroom more equitable by helping every student feel like they are an important part of the class, regardless of their ability. Grouping students with different students periodically can help them feel like they are all on the same “playing field”. In addition, allowing all students to have the same opportunities in class will promote equity. This can range from being scorekeepers to group leaders. Physical education class allows us the flexibility to promote an equitable learning environment.
kevin-bovi About 1 year ago

Reflection

As a middle-class white male middle school math teacher, my experience with privilege comes from knowing that my race, gender, and socioeconomic background are often represented in positive or neutral ways in society and in the school system. I rarely have to think about being treated unfairly based on my background, and I can generally expect to be perceived as competent and trustworthy without overcoming negative stereotypes. My experience also means that I don’t face the challenges many students from marginalized backgrounds do, which allows me to move through professional and personal spaces more easily.
In a math classroom, the curriculum and materials may feel neutral, but they often reflect the contributions and achievements of white, Western mathematicians. While math is universal, it’s easy for students to feel disconnected if they don’t see people from their own backgrounds represented in the examples or problems we discuss. For many students, especially those who come from diverse racial, cultural, and economic backgrounds, the lack of representation can signal that their identities are secondary or even invisible within the academic context.
To use my privilege to create a more equitable classroom, I can start by ensuring that I’m intentional about incorporating diverse examples, problems, and historical figures into my lessons, showing students the global and multicultural contributions to math. I can also be an ally and advocate within the school by supporting policies and practices that promote equity, such as inclusive curricula and equitable access to resources. I can encourage students to share their own perspectives and experiences, and I can strive to make my classroom a safe and welcoming place for everyone. By doing so, I can help build a classroom environment where each student feels they belong and that their identity is respected and valued.
nickolasbuckley About 1 year ago

Reflection

How do you experience privilege and marginalization? I have never felt that I have been treated unfairly. I have not experienced marginalization nor have I felt discriminated against. Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials? In science we discuss facts and processes on how things work. I feel kids see themselves as part of the process in that anyone can be successful in it. How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable? I will try to provide chances for students to express their experiences and viewpoints, such as through projects, presentations, or class discussions. Through the new NGSS we design activities that allow students to connect science to their own lives. Encourage them to explore local issues or topics of personal interest.
tomarc About 1 year ago

Reflect

I don’t feel like I experience marginalization as a privileged white male in the middle class. To create a more equitable classroom environment, I feel it’s important to incorporate diverse materials and voices. In doing so this involves diversifying curriculum to include works from various cultures and backgrounds, allowing all students to share their experiences, and listening to their feedback. It is also important to think about our own biases and build strong connections with students to understand their backgrounds and needs.
greg-soposki About 1 year ago

Reflect

I am a white, middle class, male who speaks English. Therefore, I experience much privilege and little marginalization.

In my classroom, I attempt to make as many voices heard as possible. I'm fortunate that as a Global History teacher, I have the opportunity to teach about so many different cultures throughout the world. We talk about South America, Africa, Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. We bring light the history of various groups of people and discuss the various religions as well. Therefore, we elevate as many as we can.

In my classroom, I attempt to make it a safe space where all opinions are heard and valued. 
rjayne About 1 year ago

Reflecting

I have not experienced marginalization as a privileged white American in the middle class. I have never felt discriminated against in school, while applying for jobs, or living in my community. In my classroom, I would like to think that my kids do see themselves reflected in our curriculum, but I am sure I can do better. I think we have made some great changes to the literature that we are exposing our young students to. I know my own children have read literature and received lessons that were much more accurate than when I was in school. I think our district is trying to make these small changes in the right direction but we still have more work to do.  
rebeccamc About 1 year ago

Reflect

I experience privilege as a white person who is educated, speaks English, is able bodied, and have grown up in the United States. I think sometimes I am marginalized due to being a female who identifies as gay. It seems that as I have become more educated on privilege in the last several years, I have recognized the areas in which I have privilege that prior to delving deeper I was unaware of. I think that when looking at our curriculum in New Hartford we do not see a lot of diversity immersed into it. However, I think the English department over the last few years has worked hard to try and bring some areas of diversity to light. I think when it comes to videos, training, and exposure it is important that we include more diverse discussions.
ellie-bawarski Over 1 year ago

Reflect

How do you experience privilege and marginalization?
Being a white, middle class, female, I don't feel like I've felt marginalization or been excluded due to my race, religion, gender or orientation. 

Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials?
I feel that I have a good variety of books in my classroom library and am fairly confident that each of my students is able to select books that reflect their own lives. 

How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?
I think it's important to use our own provilege to make our classrooms and school more equitable. We can do so by making our classrooms a welcoming place for everyone. 
gyanuk Over 1 year ago

Reflect

In a math setting, privilege and marginalization can still play a significant role, albeit in different ways than in other subjects. Privilege might manifest in access to resources such as expensive calculators, tutoring services, or extracurricular math programs, which can give certain students an advantage over others.  Additionally, students who come from backgrounds where math is valued and encouraged may feel more confident and motivated in their mathematical pursuits compared to those who have been discouraged or marginalized in this area.  

When it comes to curriculum and classroom materials, representation matters in math just as much as in any other subject. Teachers can use their privilege to ensure that a diverse range of mathematical perspectives and contributions are highlighted in their teaching materials.  This might involve incorporating examples from different cultures, historical contexts, and real-world applications to make math more relatable and accessible to all students.

To make the math classroom more equitable, educators can use their privilege to address disparities in access to resources and support.  This might include advocating for funding or grants to provide students with necessary tools like graphing calculators or access to online learning platforms.  Teachers can also create a supportive and inclusive learning environment where students feel comfortable asking questions, making mistakes, and exploring math in ways that resonate with their own experiences and interests.  By leveraging their privilege in these ways, math educators can help create a more equitable and empowering learning environment for all students, regardless of their background or identity.
derekrichards Over 1 year ago