NYSTC Equity Challenge-Week 5

Reflect

Only editable by group admins

  • Last updated March 31, 2022 at 3:41 AM
  • Evidence visible to public
Reflect on and answer the following questions: How do you experience privilege and marginalization? Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials? How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?

All posted evidence

Reflect

How do you experience privilege and marginalization? I don't feel like I experience marginalization. I do not feel like excluded due to age, gender, race, orientation or language. After doing the checklist in the previous activity I definitely believe I experience privilege on a daily basis and that it has helped ease my experiences and opportunity. I also believe that my privilege has been almost invisible to me up to this point in my DEI journey. I never identified myself as a privileged person or even believed I had privilege until going through Dr. Maddens course. 

Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials? In my classroom I hope that all students see themselves reflected in the classroom. Although I teach math which may be a bit more difficult to discuss privilege I do try to use and discuss these topics when we cover word problems. The names and experiences presented within the word problems in our curriculum are much more authentic then they were 5 years ago. We are headed in the right direction and need to keep working!


How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable? I would say for me it is first recognizing my privilege and then working to address and eliminate privilege and make all students educational experience equitable. The first example that comes to mind is access to supplies.
megan-turvey About 2 years ago

Reflection

Similar to my last entry, I experience privilege as a white, educated, middle-class individual.  I am employed, insured, and live in a safe community.  I don’t have to worry about a place to live or food for our family.  I grew up in the same way and have not experienced any other lifestyle.  I may experience marginalization being female. 
Content in the math curriculum is pretty straightforward I think.  There have been small changes to problems presented but only regarding names and experiences.  The names seem to be more gender-neutral and the problems or situations described are more diverse.  I feel like it is difficult to have much diversity in math but definitely needs to be seen in the literature.  
I can make my classroom more equitable by making the content more relatable to all of my students.  I also want my students to feel that my classroom is a safe learning environment.  They can come in any time to get help or just as a place they feel comfortable coming to.   
melissa7 Over 2 years ago

Reflect

How do you experience privilege and marginalization?I experience privilege because I am a White, Middle Class person.  I don't have to worry about where my next meal is coming from or how my mortgage is going to be paid next month.  However, with that being said I also have worked for all this and to get myself to this point in my life.  I know not everyone has the same resources or support system that I had growing up so I try to encourage my students and volunteer in areas where I can help individuals the way I was helped by my family and friends growing up.  I feel as though I have been marginalized in the past due to my appearance.  I have struggled with my weight much of my life and I feel that in some cases interviewing for jobs in the past that it had something to do with why I did not get some positions.  Nothing specific was every said to indicate that but it is a feeling I had when the interviews were occurring and the path that the interviews went it.

Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials?In my curriculum of Mathematics you see that most if not all of them are white males.  So it was the white male population back in the very early years that developed all the theorems and rules that we now see in Mathematics.


How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?My classroom is a safe place where I hope students feel comfortable enough to come to when they need a place to take a break from reality. Being a teenager is extremely hard so the more safe places we can give our students the better.
abrownsell Over 2 years ago

Reflection

I am privileged because I am a white, straight, middle-class individual.  I am employed and insured and live comfortably.  I grew up similarly and have not had to experience another lifestyle.  Because I am female sometimes I may experience marginalization.  I was also marginalized once due to my address.  When I was interviewing for my first teaching position, I was not chosen for the job simply because I did not graduate from the school district I was interviewing at.  I was one of two candidates left and the other individual received the job simply because he was a graduate.  I was informed of this after the interview process was completed.  It was so unfair!  I teach math, so I feel the content does not lend itself to easily viewing privilege and marginalization.  However, I have noticed the Regents exam includes problems with people having non-gender-specific names or names that are from diverse cultures.  I would like to think my classroom is equitable for all; I have created content and a curriculum that is reflective of my students. I also provide students with supplies they may need just in case the families do not have the means to obtain them on their own.  
kfoster615 Over 2 years ago

Reflect

Privilege and Marginalization
I am very privileged in many areas but have also experienced marginalization as a female. As a college student, my advisor would not let me sign up for the 'hard' science classes even though that was a primary area of interest for me. I also routinely experience different treatment in meetings and suggestions are not accepted the same if someone identifying as a man presents the same idea.

In my classroom, I work very hard to present a variety of cultures/genders/religions in the books I read to students. I want to make sure that there are examples of scientists, doctors, and leaders from every group presented.
kdavis0622 Almost 3 years ago

Reflection

As mentioned in the last entry, I experience privilege as a white, straight, middle-class individual in our community. I may experience marginalization for being a woman at times; in Privilege 101 I connected with the author sharing that as a mentally-ill woman, her problems were seen as PMS and not the PTSD she was experiencing. Primarily white individuals see themselves in our curriculum and classroom materials, though I have fewer identity-based examples in the math classroom. It is important for our examples to be diversified in the humanities classes so all students can see themselves in literature, history, etc. Our staff could make our classrooms and school more equitable by bringing in people from diverse backgrounds, including parents of students in our school community, to share ways they have felt oppressed and explain to students how they can be an advocate for their peers in our primarily white community. 
ebonomo Almost 3 years ago

Reflection

How do you experience privilege and marginalization? The survey stated that I checked 93% more than other quiz-takers, so I definitely experience privilege in many ways. I am a white, educated, heterosexual, employed, insured married individual that owns my own home. I live in a very comfortable clean safe secure community where everyone looks just like me. I grew up in a two-parent home, not far from where I live today, so I have never had the opportunity to experience a different environment or lifestyle. My marginalization comes from the mere fact that I am female. Because of this, need to work harder to succeed at many things and am sometimes discouraged from doing, saying, or having my own opinion. Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials? In the middle school math curriculum, I feel like most problems are pretty straightforward as far as content goes, however, I have seen changes in the presentation and representation of word problems over the past several years. For example, the names of people being described in a word problem are more diverse, occupations that are discussed are not so gender specific, and examples use different real-world scenarios. How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable? I can make my classroom more equitable by creating content and a curriculum that is reflective of my students. Have extra pencils, paper, and calculators available for student use. Show kindness to students who are new to the district, or compassion to those who may feel isolated or troubled. 
smassa Over 3 years ago

Reflection

How do you experience privilege and marginalization?I am privileged as a white woman who lives and works in a primarily white suburban area.  I don't feel threatened or have any fears as I come and go through my community.  I may see the marginalization as a woman working in a man's world.  Things have changed but there is still a ways to go.  I know of local companies that have just recently hired a man and woman for the same positions but the man was offered more money.  This was brought up in a community meeting that I attended. 

Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials? I look at the reading material and social studies textbooks and can see privileged individuals throughout.  Until I started taking workshops that really forced us to look deeper and become more focused I never really noticed it, since everyone looked like me.

How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?  I have been trying to find materials that work for the whole group.  I want to make sure every group is being represented.  We need to make all individuals are represented when we are teaching.
diane-kain Over 3 years ago

privilege reflection

*How do you experience privilege and marginalization? I am a fairly privileged individual. By default, as a woman in a patriarchal society, I experience certain marginalizations as a result of my gender. I do not believe that I have ever been marginalized due to my race, though I likely have experienced privilege - and given my privilege, I don’t recognize it.

*Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials? Students of Latinx or Spanish heritage can see themselves and their lives reflected in my classroom’s curriculum. (There’s an awesome presentation on Cultural Diversity in Latin America that was added to the curriculum this year! I’ll share it with you… unless I forget! Remind me?)

*Consider how your own practices could be perpetuating systemic privilege. How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable? I don’t believe that my practices do perpetuate systemic privilege… I use my classroom as a place to introduce new cultures, people, and language to my students – and the people from Spanish-speaking countries cover the whole spectrum of (color). Also, as a mother of bi-racial Latina daughters, I feel that I am more aware of what I say and do knowing how others experience life… but perhaps everyone else behaves the same way that I do?!

bethany-turo Over 3 years ago

How do you experience privilege and marginalization?

How do you experience privilege and marginalization? I experience privilege because I am white, heterosexual. Everywhere I go almost everyone looks like me and I blend in. I don't "stand out in the crowd".  I experience Marginalization because I am a women. Many men still see our gender as not being able to do certain things as well as they can and we are not paid as much as our male counterparts doing the same job. In our curriculum many of the lessons are around white characters and their lives. If given the opportunity I can help make our classroom material more diverse. I would like to use more materials geared around the different ethnicities that we have in our classroom and hope that at least one of my students sees someone like them doing great things and it inspires them.
tracy-fountain Over 3 years ago

reflections

“How do you experience privilege and marginalization?”  I experience privileges every day.  I am white, heterosexual, and belong to no fringe groups.  I pretty much blend in with groups and no one pays me any attention.  I am invisible.  I do feel that women of all races are still a marginalized group.  We still have men thinking we are not capable of doing everything they can, and we are typically not paid as much as men.  “Who sees themselves and their own lives reflected in our curriculum and our classroom materials?”  Our curriculum mostly reflects a white male perspective.  This is getting better though.  I see more and more of the reading selections in English classes are from different perspectives, and the students are learning other points of view in our History classes as well.  We do need to get better at incorporating other perspectives, races, and genders into our curriculum though.“How might you use your own privilege to make your classroom and school more equitable?”  I can make my classroom a more welcoming place for everyone by including more perspectives from other cultures, races, and genders into the classroom.
cpiazza Over 3 years ago